During the initial article
A Brief Review of the
Background History and Use of the ASTM Standard E 1300
for Glass Analysis in the December 2011 issue,
it was referenced that a continuation of the history of
the ASTM E 1300 standard would venture into the changes
and updated additions of the standard that have occurred
in the new millennium since year 2000. This article will
delve into the work that has occurred since 2000.
In 2000, charts were made bigger, and more legible,
allowing easier interpolation between load lines.
Conversion factors were added for load durations other
than 60 seconds and 30 days. Related to this was the
addition of how to combine loads of different durations.
One of the most important additions to the 2000 revision
was an effort assist evaluation of even more complex
designs not covered in the standard. Examples of this
are point supported glass, non-rectangular shapes, and
edge supported conditions other than four edge. It was
recognized that engineers and designers were analyzing
these types of designs, but with no consensus set of
maximum values for edge stress and surface stress. The
addition of tables addressing these values in the
appendix of E 1300 was a major contribution for
standardization.
Several major changes occurred in the 2002 version of
the standard. For one, in that same year the industry
began changing how wind speed and pressure (Windload)
were addressed in the US. Previously, Windload was
averaged over 60 second duration. In 2002, the American
Society of Civil Engineers agreed to change their
standard on determining design loads (ASCE 7) from 60
seconds to a 3 second gust. After much debate and
discussion about this topic within the ASTM task group,
it was decided to rework all twelve of the existing load
chart, making adjustments for 3 second load duration.
In addition, there had been extensive work by DuPont
showing that the factors for laminated glass currently
used in E 1300 were too conservative. This work resulted
in establishment of separate load charts for laminated
glass.
Previously, the document assumed that glass was
always supported on 4 sides. In the 2002 revision,
charts were added to address design loads in 1, 2, and 3
side support conditions. With this revision the document
expanded to 59 pages. There were 42 load charts, 5
tables of factors, and 13 procedures covering various
glass constructions. There was much concern about
complexity and the need for a computer program to keep
track of the logistics required to obtain a result.
Unfortunately, ASTM as an organization does not promote
the writing of sanctioned computer software, although
others were free to do so.
Editorial changes and revised glass type factors were
made in the 2003 version of the standard. Prior to 2004,
only polyvinyl butyral (PVB) interlayers for laminated
glass were recognized. In order to accommodate other
interlayer materials, the 2004 revision included a
procedure for establishing equivalency to PVB. The basis
for equivalency was to provide evidence through a
standardized test (ASTM D 4065), that the non-PVB
interlayer had an equal or greater lower bound Young’s
Modulus of 1.5 MPa, and a shear modulus of 0.4 MPa.
In 2007, definitions for the designation of laminated
glass were revised. Since there are many layup
combinations of laminated glass with varying glass ply
thickness and interlayer thickness, and a "designated"
laminated glass thickness was necessary for determining
which load chart is appropriate. In this update the load
charts were adjusted once again this time to accommodate
larger size glass plates in thicker glasses. Sizes as
large as 120" x 250" (3050 mm x 6350 mm) and larger
could now be evaluated.
The most recent version of the standard at this
writing is the 2009 edition. This revision added a
procedure for analyzing triple glazing. This procedure
again assumed load share is proportional to stiffness of
the plate and determined load share factors based on the
cube of the thickness. Also added was a procedure for
determining the "effective thickness" of laminated
glass. This procedure is provided for use in independent
stress analysis for design situations not covered in the
main document of E 1300. There is committee work going
on at present to add to and improve the standard
further. Stay tuned for the next version that is
expected to release in 2012.